Tools

The New York Times Cooking App Tests AI Recipe Modifications, Draws Mixed User Response

NYT Cooking is rolling out an AI feature that helps users modify recipes with ingredient substitutions and serving scaling, sparking privacy and sustainability concerns among subscribers.

Last verified:

AI Recipe Adaptation Arrives at The New York Times Cooking

According to The Verge AI, The New York Times Cooking app is testing an AI-powered feature that helps subscribers customize recipes in real time. The tool, announced last Friday by Cooking senior editor Genevieve Ko, recommends ingredient substitutions while explaining how swaps affect cooking steps, suggests alternative equipment, and scales recipes to any serving size. The feature is currently available to all Cooking subscribers on the iOS app and will roll out more broadly “soon,” according to Ko. Modified recipes remain private and cannot be published or shared within the app.

How the Tool Works in Practice

The AI modification system operates as an optional add-on rather than a mandatory layer. One example cited in The Verge’s coverage shows a user substituting baby spinach for kale—the AI advises adding spinach later in cooking because it wilts faster than kale. According to Ko, the feature can also adapt recipes around different cookware and kitchen tools available to individual users. The New York Times spokesperson Jordan Cohen confirmed to The Verge that the Cooking team monitored the feature’s performance before this wider rollout.

Subscriber Concerns Over Environmental and User-Experience Impact

User response has been mixed, with some subscribers expressing reservations in the article’s comment section. According to The Verge, commenters raised concerns about the environmental footprint of widespread AI adoption and the potential impact on the Cooking app’s interface simplicity. One subscriber described the integration as “unbelievably disappointing,” noting that the app had historically offered “a wonderful and simple collection of recipes and notes from all sorts of different people.” The Verge notes that The New York Times kept comments open for four days to allow the Cooking editorial team to respond directly to reader feedback before closing the thread.

AI Has Quietly Enhanced NYT Cooking Before

This is not the first time algorithmic tools have reshaped the NYT Cooking experience. According to Ko’s statement to The Verge, AI was deployed two years ago to convert imperial volume measurements to metric weight across the recipe database. A serving-adjustment feature—which halves or doubles original serving sizes—was added last year. The new modification system represents a more interactive and personalized evolution of these earlier AI applications.

Why This Matters

The NYT Cooking AI feature signals how subscription-based content platforms are embedding generative AI into consumer workflows without hard opt-out controls. For recipe-centric users, the tool may genuinely reduce friction—scaling, substituting, and adapting recipes on the fly addresses real pain points. However, the lack of a disable toggle and the subscription-model bundling (users cannot remove AI access without abandoning the app) raise questions about consent and feature bloat that will likely shape how other media properties roll out AI tooling. The early user pushback may pressure The New York Times to reconsider its communication strategy, though the company’s framing of the feature as “completely optional to use” suggests the distinction between availability and non-use will remain contested.

Frequently Asked Questions

What can the NYT Cooking AI modification feature do?

The tool recommends ingredient substitutions (explaining how they affect cooking steps), suggests equipment alternatives, and scales recipes to any number of servings. Modified recipes remain private and cannot be shared through the app.

Is the AI feature mandatory for NYT Cooking subscribers?

No. According to The New York Times, the feature is completely optional to use, though there is currently no toggle to disable it entirely.

Why are some subscribers concerned about the feature?

Comment-section feedback cited environmental concerns about AI adoption and worries that AI integration would diminish the user experience of the Cooking app.

Has the NYT Cooking app used AI before?

Yes. According to Cooking senior editor Genevieve Ko, AI was previously used to convert imperial measurements to metric weight two years ago, and a serving-size doubling/halving feature was added last year.

#ai #consumer-products #nyt-cooking #recipe-modification