Policy

New York Times and Regional Publishers Sue Brave Browser for AI Training Scraping and Paywall Bypass

Major publications allege Brave Software scraped content without permission and sold access to AI firms including Anthropic and Perplexity.

Last verified:

The New York Times, alongside three regional publishers, filed lawsuits against Brave Software on November 2, alleging systematic copyright infringement through web scraping and paywall circumvention. According to The Verge, the complaint centers on two related claims: that Brave scraped journalistic content without permission and then monetized access to that content by selling it to generative AI companies including Anthropic, Perplexity, Mistral, xAI, and Cohere.

The Brave Index: A Monetized Content Pipeline

The lawsuit alleges that Brave Software operates what it calls the “Brave Index”—a searchable archive of scraped website content that the company offers to AI firms on a commercial basis. According to The Verge’s reporting of the complaint, these AI companies use the indexed content for two purposes: to train their models or to “respond to specific user queries” with real-time information.

The New York Daily News, Chicago Tribune, and Orlando Sentinel jointly filed a separate suit making identical allegations, with attorney Steven Lieberman characterizing the arrangement as a scheme in which Brave acts as an intermediary: “AI giants are now desperate to avoid getting caught red-handed stealing news from publishers, so Brave Software is selling them a back door to the journalism they know they have no right to.” The complaint explicitly states that Brave “has never compensated the Publishers for the unlawful use, copying, and distribution of the Publishers’ copyrighted content.”

Paywall Circumvention as Secondary Harm

Beyond the AI training claims, the lawsuit identifies a second mechanism of infringement: Brave’s “Paywall blocker” feature, which The Verge reports allows users to bypass subscription barriers on hundreds of major publishers’ websites without consent. The complaint asserts that Brave “has taken other steps that prevent the Publishers from blocking Brave’s access to the Publishers’ websites,” suggesting active technical measures to circumvent anti-scraping defenses.

Responses and Dismissals

Graham James, a New York Times spokesperson, told The Verge: “While we believe in the ethical and responsible use and development of AI, Brave has flouted established copyright law and ignored repeated requests by The Times to stop its infringing conduct.”

Brave, Anthropic, Mistral, and Cohere did not immediately respond to The Verge’s request for comment. However, Perplexity’s chief communications officer Jesse Dwyer dismissed the lawsuit, stating: “The New York Times is overpaying its attorneys and underpaying its journalists. (Who could’ve easily identified the disinformation in this suit.)” His response suggests Perplexity views the copyright allegations as unfounded rather than addressing the specific claim that the company purchased scraped content from Brave.

Why This Matters

This lawsuit represents an escalation in the copyright conflict between news publishers and AI companies—but it targets an intermediate actor (Brave) rather than the AI firms directly. By suing the browser maker for operating the scraping infrastructure, publishers may be attempting to establish liability upstream in the supply chain. If successful, the ruling could complicate the legal and business models of browser-based content indexing services and force negotiations around what constitutes authorized AI training data. The case also tests whether paywall-circumvention features constitute contributory copyright infringement under US law, a question that has remained largely unresolved for commercial browsers.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Brave's 'Brave Index' and who has access to it?

According to The Verge, Brave Software monetizes an index of scraped websites by offering AI companies paid access to real-time online content. The lawsuit alleges Anthropic, Perplexity, Mistral, xAI, and Cohere have received this access.

Did Brave ask publishers for permission before scraping?

No. The complaint states Brave 'has never asked for the Publishers' permission to access their websites, much less to copy the material and provide it to users or other AI companies.'

What is the 'Paywall blocker' feature?

According to the lawsuit, Brave promotes a browser feature that allows users to bypass paywalls on hundreds of top publishers' websites without publisher consent.

How did AI companies respond?

Most companies did not immediately reply. Perplexity's chief communications officer Jesse Dwyer dismissed the lawsuit as frivolous, claiming the Times is 'overpaying its attorneys and underpaying its journalists.'

#copyright #ai-scraping #brave-browser #paywalls #generative-ai