Industry

Meta's Apocalyptic AI Ad Uses David Bowie's 'Five Years'—and Critics Say the Irony Is Intentional

Meta's new advertisement pairs an optimistic message about AI connecting people with a 1972 David Bowie song originally written about Earth's final years.

Last verified:

Meta Pairs Apocalypse Song With AI Optimism

Meta released an advertisement on Thursday to its official Instagram account promoting artificial intelligence as a tool that will deepen human connection rather than isolate people. According to Wired AI, the 60-second spot features scenes of intimate human moments—a toddler playing with a butterfly, parents laughing with an infant, and basketball player Jalen Brunson waving at a New York Knicks Championship Parade—while a narrator declares, “Call us optimists, call us dreamers, call us whatever the hell you want—but we’re betting on people, and we like those odds.” The ad also showcases Meta’s smart glasses in non-intrusive contexts, sidestepping the company’s fraught history with privacy concerns.

The ad’s musical choice, however, has become the focal point of cultural criticism. Meta selected David Bowie’s 1972 composition “Five Years,” a song that originally chronicles a dystopian future in which Earth has precisely five years remaining before extinction. The apocalyptic opening—“News had just come over / We had five years left to cry in”—is absent from the ad, which instead isolates the verses about human connection: “I never thought I’d need so many people.” According to Wired AI, Meta spokesperson Francis Brennan defended the selection by citing a 1972 Bowie quote sourced to BowieBible.com: “People are so incredibly serious and scared of the future that I would wish to turn the feeling the other way, into a wave of optimism.”

The Song’s True Meaning Versus Meta’s Framing

BowieBible.com provides context that complicates Meta’s interpretation. The source notes the song “speaks of a dystopian nightmare in which Earth enters its final five years, for reasons undisclosed, and the ensuing panic, violence, and attempts at redemption.” Drummer Mick Woodmansey, who performed on the original recording, told an interviewer in 2018 that the composition was “pretty depressing,” and that Bowie was “actually in tears” while recording the vocal track.

Jeremy D. Larson, deputy director of Pitchfork (a sister publication under Condé Nast), told Wired AI that excising songs from their original context for commercial purposes is industry convention. He cited a Carnival Cruise advertisement that uses Iggy Pop’s song about heroin addiction to illustrate how far brands routinely stretch artistic meaning. Larson also noted that Warner Chappell Music, which owns Bowie’s catalog, retains approval authority over commercial placements—making the licensing choice a corporate decision beyond Meta’s unilateral control.

Why This Matters

The ad highlights a persistent tension in corporate messaging: the difference between a tone-deaf creative decision and a deliberately provocative one. For marketing teams evaluating AI adoption and brand positioning, Meta’s choice raises questions about whether layering optimistic messaging over dystopian source material signals confidence in technology or reveals discomfort with the underlying anxiety that AI generates in many consumers. The ad’s reliance on Bowie’s own statements about optimism—rather than the song’s lyrical content—suggests Meta is banking on audiences either not knowing the source material or valuing the artistic pedigree more than the message. As regulatory scrutiny of AI intensifies and public skepticism of tech platforms persists, such messaging choices will likely face increasing cultural interrogation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main message of Meta's new AI ad?

Meta's ad argues that artificial intelligence will not isolate people or leave them behind, using scenes of human connection and interaction with AI-enabled products like smart glasses.

Why is using 'Five Years' controversial?

The song, written by David Bowie in 1972, depicts Earth entering its final five years due to an undisclosed apocalyptic event. Meta's ad excerpts only the optimistic lyrics about human connection, omitting the dystopian narrative.

Who owns the rights to use David Bowie's music?

According to Wired AI, Warner Chappell Music owns Bowie's catalog and holds discretion over commercial licensing, not Meta directly.

What do music critics say about using songs out of context in ads?

Jeremy D. Larson, deputy director of Pitchfork, notes that removing songs from their original context for commercials is standard practice in advertising, citing examples like Carnival Cruise using Iggy Pop's heroin-addiction song.

#meta #advertising #ai-marketing #david-bowie #brand-strategy