Macmillan's AI Assistant Flop: From Launch Party to Quiet Sunset
Macmillan Publishers' enterprise AI tool NOA, introduced with fanfare in January 2024, was quietly discontinued in October 2025 after staff found it unreliable and largely unused.
Last verified:
The Launch Party That Preceded Failure
Macmillan Publishers greeted January 2024 with an unusual office celebration: a formal launch party for an AI assistant named NOA. According to Wired AI, the Lower Manhattan headquarters was decorated with purple balloons, marquee lettering spelling out “NOA IS HERE,” and a doughnut plate arranged to match. The fanfare introduced NOA—short for No Ordinary Assistant—as an enterprise chatbot developed by Chaptr, a software subsidiary backed by Holtzbrinck, Macmillan’s parent company.
The introduction email promised staff a “safe environment” where they could input proprietary information without risk of third-party data sharing, positioning NOA as a closed-loop internal tool. Training sessions instructed employees to use it for composing emails, drafting marketing copy, generating ideas, and research—though staff were cautioned that NOA could hallucinate and required human fact-checking. Later in 2024, the company even encouraged employees to use NOA to draft their performance review goals through a “specialized prompt.”
Why Staff Rejected the Tool
The celebratory debut masked fundamental dysfunction. Wired AI reports that multiple Macmillan employees found NOA “unhelpful and unreliable,” with one describing it simply as “terrible, and no one used it.” Several staff members also characterized the acronym itself as offensive to the publisher’s existing human assistants, whom the AI system was ostensibly meant to complement rather than replace.
The tool’s reception underscores a recurring friction point in enterprise AI adoption: the gap between marketing promises and operational reality. Despite reassurances from Chaptr representatives during training sessions, the system failed to deliver utility in the high-stakes domain of publishing, where content accuracy and editorial judgment are non-negotiable.
The Pivot to Google Gemini
In October 2025—less than two years after the office party—Macmillan staff received notice via company-wide email that Chaptr would be discontinuing NOA. According to Wired AI, leadership has since begun integrating Google Gemini into Macmillan’s publishing workflows. However, the transition has not stabilized outcomes: some editors who experimented with using Gemini to evaluate submission letters from literary agents reported the AI-generated evaluations were “useless.”
Why This Matters
Macmillan’s experience illustrates a pattern emerging across enterprise AI adoption: high-visibility launches often precede quiet disappointments. Publishing is particularly unforgiving terrain for generative AI—the stakes involve author relationships, content quality, and legal liability—yet neither NOA nor the subsequent Gemini integration has achieved editorial confidence.
For HR and operations teams considering enterprise AI tools, the lesson is sobering: no amount of office-party enthusiasm can substitute for genuine operational utility. Macmillan’s shift from a proprietary, vendor-locked tool (Chaptr’s NOA) to a third-party commercial model (Google Gemini) also signals a broader industry realization: organizations may lack both the technical depth and the financial leverage to sustain proprietary AI platforms designed by smaller vendors. Whether Gemini will fare better remains an open question—early editorial feedback suggests the underlying problem isn’t the vendor, but the fit between current LLM capabilities and the nuanced judgment publishing demands.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was NOA and why did Macmillan introduce it?
NOA (No Ordinary Assistant) was an enterprise AI chatbot built by Chaptr, Macmillan's parent company Holtzbrinck's software division. It was marketed as a proprietary, closed-loop tool for internal use on tasks like email composition, marketing research, and manuscript drafting.
Why did staff find NOA offensive?
Multiple Macmillan employees viewed the acronym as dismissive of the company's human assistants, whose roles the AI tool ostensibly supplemented.
What replaced NOA after its shutdown?
Macmillan has been integrating Google Gemini into its publishing workflows, though early editorial trials have yielded mixed results, with some editors describing the output as 'useless.'
When was NOA discontinued?
Macmillan staff were notified of NOA's discontinuation via company-wide email in October 2025, roughly 21 months after its launch.